All Seasons

Season 1

  • S01E01 Catholic Church vs. Oprah

    • March 12, 2008
    • Comedy Central

    Greg Giraldo and Paul F. Tompkins argue the case of "Catholic Church vs. Oprah."

  • S01E02 Donald Trump vs. Viagra

    • March 19, 2008
    • Comedy Central

    Lewis Black hears the case of "Donald Trump vs. Viagra" from advocates Greg Giraldo and Andy Kindler.

  • S01E03 Beer vs. Weed

    • March 26, 2008
    • Comedy Central

    Paul F. Tompkins and Andrew Daly argue on which is the bigger vice: Beer or Weed?

  • S01E04 YouTube vs. Porn

    • April 2, 2008
    • Comedy Central

    Greg Giraldo and Patton Oswalt plead the pros and cons of Pornography and YouTube as the ultimate vice.

  • S01E05 Paris Hilton vs. Dick Cheney

    • April 9, 2008
    • Comedy Central

    Lewis Black hears from Greg Giraldo and Patton Oswalt on who is worse: Paris Hilton or Dick Cheney?

  • S01E06 High School vs. American Idol

    • April 16, 2008
    • Comedy Central

    Lewis Black must decide which is more evil: High school or American Idol, as argued by Patton Oswalt and Andy Kindler.

  • S01E07 Kim Jong-Il vs. Tila Tequila

    • April 23, 2008
    • Comedy Central

    Lewis Black hears from Greg Giraldo and Kathleen Madigan on who is worse: Kim Jong-Il or Tila Tequila?

  • S01E08 Las Vegas vs. The Human Body

    • April 30, 2008
    • Comedy Central

    Lewis Black hears arguments from Andrew Daly and Patton Oswalt on the evils of Las Vegas and the Human Body.

Season 2

  • S02E01 Ultimate Fighting vs. Bloggers

    • July 30, 2008
    • Comedy Central

    Andy Daly and Patton Oswalt argue the case of "Ultimate Fighting vs. Bloggers" in the season 2 premiere of the show.

  • S02E02 Steroids vs. Boobjobs

    • August 6, 2008
    • Comedy Central

    Greg Giraldo and Andrew Daly argue over muscle-enhancing Steoids versus chestsize-enhancing Boobjobs. Which is the Root of All Evil?

  • S02E03 Olympic Games vs. Drinking Games

    • August 13, 2008
    • Comedy Central

    Andy Daly and Greg Giraldo must decide which is more pointless: the Olympic Games or Drinking games.

  • S02E04 NRA vs. PETA

    • August 20, 2008
    • Comedy Central

    Andy Kindler and Paul F. Tompkins square off over the NRA vs. PETA.

  • S02E05 Red States vs. Blue States

    • August 27, 2008
    • Comedy Central

    Paul F. Tompkins and Patton Oswalt argue the divide between red states and blue states - which are more evil?

  • S02E06 Disney vs. Scientology

    • September 3, 2008
    • Comedy Central

    Kathleen Madigan and Andy Kindler go head to head in a battle over the greater of two evils: Disney or Scientology.

  • S02E07 Going Green vs. Spring Break

    • September 10, 2008
    • Comedy Central

    Greg Giraldo and Andrea Savage debate: environmentalism or partying without a care?

  • S02E08 Gen X vs. Boomers

    • September 17, 2008
    • Comedy Central

    Paul F. Tompkins and Andy Daly debate over the Gen X and the baby boomer generations.

  • S02E09 Strip Clubs vs. Sororities

    • September 24, 2008
    • Comedy Central

    Kathleen Madigan and Greg Giraldo return to debate which is more evil, strip clubs or sororities.

  • S02E10 The Hills vs. Rocket Scientists

    • October 1, 2008
    • Comedy Central

    The second season finale has Jerry Minor and Paul Tompkins debating the evils of rocket science and the MTV show The Hills.

Additional Specials