25 years of blood, sweat and tears has paid off for Vinny, founder of the Everyman Theater. Together with the theater's manager, Jon, the two are planning a blowout 25th anniversary party to kick off their new season, a dual showcase of two classic American plays. They want a cake that will wow their 400 guests and showcase all of their hard work and success. But Vinny wants a glitzy cake that pays tribute to the theater's humble roots, while Jon wants a cake that spotlights the two plays in the muted tones of the stage design. Will these two find the script to the perfect cake for this massive celebration before the curtain parts?