Revisiting one of the largest scientific controversies of the 20th century; the dispute that began with an ethics question over a single biology paper caught the attention of the national media and US congress, and had lasting repercussions on how scientific misconduct cases are investigated even 40 years later. This Nebula Original focuses on the role of bias in this story, how preconceived notions can affect an audience’s view on a complex web of testimony and evidence while reconstructing historical events through archival news coverage, congressional testimony, and brand new first-hand interviews.