Alex's grandmother is making Thanksgiving dinner but forgot the apple pie. Cookie Monster and Gonger only have one apple but need lots of chopped up apples so they visit an orchard to complete their apple pie recipe for Thanksgiving dessert.
Sally would like a cranberry muffin for breakfast, but Cookie Monster has eaten the "Tall, fluffy cookies" and Gonger realizes they're all out of "cran-ba-berries." To get more cranberries, Cookie Monster and Gonger go to a cranberry bog to observe how cranberries are grown and harvested.
Cleo has just finished reading Goldilocks and would like to try porridge. Cookie Monster doesn't know what porridge is and calls Baby Bear who tells him porridge is oatmeal. To get more oats, Cookie Monster and Gonger go to an oat factory.
While making a half-mushroom/half-pineapple pizza for identical twins Kelly and Karla, Cookie tries to make up for eating the pineapple by sticking a pine cone with an apple and making a "pine-apple...cone" which upsets Chef Gonger. Gonger and Cookie Monster travel to a pineapple farm for the "pine-app-apple" for a pizza making party!
Maya would like a fruit salad snack for her cousin Enjoli's visit. Since Cookie has eaten all the "grapies" needed for the fruit salad, Gonger and Cookie Monster take the truck to the vineyard for more. They also learn raisins come from grapes.
Teresa's cat Panchita loves tuna fish and she would like Cookie Monster and Gonger to make her a tuna fish sandwich. Cookie Monster says no problem because they are "Kitty Cat Lovers," Gonger corrects him "Monster Foodies." They have everything they need except avocados, so they go to an avocado farm for more.
Manny would like a healthy meal of angel hair pasta and vegetables. Cookie Monster wonders why he wants to eat hair, so Gonger explains it's just the name of a thin noodle, but they're all out of noodles. Cookie Monster and Gonger visit the pasta factory to get more noodles.
Nituna has just finished a book about another Native American girl who eats succotash and would like to try it herself. Cookie Monster has eaten all the onions, giving him bad breath, so they venture to the farm to get more.
The Monster Foodies visit a factory where they make taco shells.
Rylan would like something round for breakfast, so Gonger decides they should make "pancakeys" but they're all out of fresh maple syrup. Cookie Monster and Gonger visit the maple tree farm where they harvest and process the syrup.
Samara would like a birthday cake as a surprise for a friend, but they're all out of "heggs." Cookie Monster and Gonger visit a chicken farm to get eggs for a birthday cake, which turns out to be for Cookie Monster.
Gonger needs to help his "grandmamama" bake her buttermilk biscuits for the neighborhood after she hurt her arm, but they need the secret ingredient, honey, to complete the recipe. Cookie Monster and Gonger travel to a bee farm to get the honey.
Aman wants to do something kind for his friends on a hot day. Gonger comes up with the idea to make fruit smoothies but Cookie Monster has finished off the carton of milk. To the Dairy Farm!
Jenny Slate visits Cookie Monster and Gonger in the food truck. She'd like them to help her take her granola and make fruit sushi for breakfast. Before Gonger can gather all the ingredients, Cookie Monster and Jenny have eaten all the yogurt. Fortunately, Gonger has some locked up in the refrigerator.
Ellie Kemper is looking for a healthy snack to enjoy during the big game and wants Cookie Monster and Gonger to whip up some nachos out of zucchini -- Zachos! Cookie Monster has all the ingredients but Ellie ate the cheese for the Zachos. Not a problem, Chef Gonger has more. This segment later aired as part of Episode 5006.
Zooey Deschanel needs Cookie Monster and Gonger's help to make a fun healthy snack her kids will enjoy using the strawberries from her garden. She wants to make silly Monster Faces out of fruit.
Gonger and Cookie get Brussels sprouts from a farm to make stir fry.
Gonger and Cookie get strawberry jelly from a factory to make a peanut butter and jelly sandwich for the Amazing Mumford.
Gonger and Cookie get cinnamon from the forest to make cinnamon toast.
Gonger and Cookie get ketchup from a factory to make a veggie burger.
Gonger and Cookie go to a peanut farm to get peanut butter and make sandwiches with peanut butter and apple slices.
Gonger and Cookie go to a banana farm to make banana chips for Zooey Deschanel.
Gonger and Cookie go to a corn field to make cornbread.
Gonger and Cookie go to a mushroom farm to make mushroom quiche.
Gonger and Cookie go to a vanilla farm to make dog-safe treats for a new dog, because Gonger used up the vanilla to make pudding.
Gonger and Cookie dress as superheros before going to a seaweed farm to make a California sushi roll for a girl dressed as a superhero.
Gonger and Cookie go to a pumpkin patch to make pumpkin soup for a boy whose brother is in the hospital.
Gonger and Cookie go to a cactus patch to make nopales tacos for a boy who wants to surprise his dad with something he didn't think he could eat.
Gonger and Cookie go to a chocolate factory to add chocolate to some s'mores for a girl at camp.
Gonger and Cookie go to an orchard to get starfruit to make food that looks like art.
Gonger and Cookie go to a farm to get peas to make pea soup for Princess Polly.
Gonger and Cookie go to a farm to get artichokes to make dino dip for Mia and her sister pretending to be paleontologists.
Gonger and Cookie go to a deli to get mozzarella cheese to make a Caprese salad for a girl who plays guitar.
Gonger and Cookie go to a rice field to get rice to make vegetable fried rice for two brothers playing pretend chef.
Gonger and Cookie learn where salt comes from to get salt to make pretzels for a girl who wants a twisty snack.
Gonger and Cookie go to a beet farm to get beets to make a beet-and-watermelon salad for a boy who wants a block-shaped snack for his sister.
Gonger and Cookie go to a mango orchard to get mangoes to make mango salsa for a girl who wants to give her teacher tortilla chips.
Gonger and Cookie go to a mustard factory to get mustard for a turkey sandwich for a girl and her sister.
Gonger and Cookie have everything they need to make a green-fruit salad, but Cookie made a kiwi into a toy, so they go to a kiwi farm to get a kiwi.
Gonger and Cookie have everything they need for a cocoa-cashew smoothie, but Cookie eats the cashews because they remind him of the letter C. So they go to a farm to get more cashews.
Gonger and Cookie want to make linguine with garlic and olive oil. They have linguine and garlic, but not olive oil, so they go to the olive grove to get more.
Cookie Monster thinks he has everything in order to make hummus, until he realizes a chickpea isn't actually a baby chicken with a pea, so he and Gonger go to a chickpea farm.
Cookie Monster and Gonger need to make a blueberry trail mix. The only problem is Cookie ate all the blueberries, so they go to the blueberry farm to get more.
A boy and his sister request something block-shaped, so Gonger decides to make baked tofu with vegetables. Cookie devours their tofu while checking the ingredients, so they visit a tofu factory to get more.
Cookie and Gonger need to make french fries that are colorful, so they go to the sweet potato farm for an orange ingredient.
Cookie and Gonger need mint leaves for iced tea, but Cookie only spared two when eating them. This isn't enough (despite being more than usual), so they go to the mint farm for more.
Cookie and Gonger seem to have everything they need to make watermelon ice pops, until they realize the watermelon is actually a cucumber, so they go to the watermelon patch to get a real one.
Cookie and Gonger need to make celery butterflies for a girl whose dentist requests crunchy fruits and vegetables. They gather everything they need and notice they are out of celery. Cookie suggests they "stalked away" before admitting to eating them. To the celery farm!
Cookie and Gonger need to make cauliflower rice, but somehow Cookie managed to eat the one thing they need right before they need it, so they head to the cauliflower farm.
Cookie Monster doesn't immediately realize his log-shaped toy is actually a crucial ingredient of goat cheese pasta, so he eats it. Now he and Gonger need to go to the goat farm.
Cookie Monster devours the last of the spinach meant for apple-spinach baby food, so he and Gonger drive to the spinach farm.
Cookie Monster learns that a butter sculpture of a sunflower is not the definition of sunflower butter, so he and Gonger head to the sunflower butter factory to get what they actually need.
Cookie and Gonger head to the zucchini farm to make zucchini noodles, a worm-looking food for a bird-loving child.
Cookie Monster eats all the pickles needed for two girls' cheese and pickle sandwiches, so he and Gonger go to the pickle factory for more.
Cookie Monster's tummy ate all the plums necessary for plum pie, so he and Gonger go to the plum orchard for more.
Baby Bear wants an ocean-themed treat to brighten up his rainy day, so Cookie and Gonger make a beach pudding cup. They have every ingredient except for vanilla bean, so they make a trip to the vanilla bean farm.
An Anything Muppet boy named Max (Noel MacNeal) requests some egg cups to give him energy for his hike. The recipe calls for lowfat milk, but the monsters are fresh out. Cookie brings in a Muppet cow, but Gonger insists that they go to the dairy farm instead.
Narf (Tyler Bunch) asks for breakfast for his bicycle ride tomorrow. Cookie Monster has most of the ingredients, but also has a couple goats, having misheard "oats," so they visit the oat factory.
Gonger and Cookie go to a farm to get eggplants to make baba ghanoush with pita bread.
Gonger and Cookie go to a farm to get plantains to make tostones with a side of mojo.
Gonger and Cookie go to a farm to get coconuts to make grater cake.
Gonger and Cookie go to a farm to get black beans to make black bean and cheese arepas.
Gonger and Cookie go to a farm to get mung bean to make Vietnamese spring rolls.
Gonger and Cookie obtain garlic from Farmer Ken to make guacamole using a molcajete, a bowl made of rock.
Cookie and Gonger need more than just one pine nut for pesto pasta, so they go to the pine tree forest for more.
Cookie and Gonger go to a farm to get a honeydew to make honeydew melon bingsu, since Gonger ate the last honeydew as a snack.
Gonger teaches Cookie to put food scraps in the compost bin before they go to a farm to get quinoa to make a quinoa breakfast bowl with peaches.
Gonger thinks the alphabet pasta is gone, until Cookie reveals he hid it so Gonger wouldn't notice he ate the tomatoes. They then go to a tomato farm in order to make Mexican alphabet soup (sopa de letras).
Cookie tries to pass off bananas on a string as string beans before he and Gonger go to a farm to get string beans for a girl who wants something that looks like grass to give to her dog.
Cookie and Gonger go to a farm to get lentils to make red lentil dahl for two kids whose grandparents are coming over from India.
Cookie and Gonger have every ingredient they need for cherry pie until Cookie eats all but one of the cherries, so they go to the cherry orchard for more.
Cookie and Gonger have salt, but nothing else, so they head to the farm for some edamame to put it on.
Cookie and Gonger go to the açaí berry farm for some açaí berry purée, as Cookie maybe ate the last of their stash.
Percy the parrot allegedly ate the last of the papaya, so Cookie and Gonger head to the papaya farm for more.
Cookie and Gonger have many orange things, but no oranges, so they go to the orange grove for some.
Cookie ate all the figs, and unable to substitute them with pigs, he and Gonger head to the fig orchard.
Cookie and Gonger have no asparagus in their letter "A" food bin, so they "aspara-go" to the asparagus farm.
Cookie and Gonger need maple syrup for roasted vegetables, but they used the last of their stash throwing a pancake party. They head to the forest for more... On location footage reused from previous "Maple Syrup" segment.
Cookie accidentally sucks up the cinnamon for meghli into his vacuum, so he and Gonger go to the forest for more. On location footage reused from previous "Cinnamon" segment.
Cookie tries to distract Gonger with a pineapple puppet so he doesn't notice Cookie ate the pineapple. They go to a farm to get a pineapple for pineapple paletas. On location footage reused from previous "Pineapple" segment.
Two kids ask for a healthy and delicious dessert, which Cookie thinks is impossible, so he puts the truck up for sale, which excites Ernie and Prairie Dawn. Gonger then says they can make chocolatey mousse. Cookie tries to distract Gonger with a bunny (Stephanie D'Abruzzo) so he doesn't notice he ate the avocados before they go to the farm for more. On location footage reused from previous "Avocado" segment.
