In his very first case as a judge in Mango Park District Court, Judge James Porter faces his predecessor Charles O'Brien. The disgraced former Judge O'Brien unlawfully imprisoned innocents for years until a police investigation uncovered his corrupt scheme, leaving his successor Judge Porter to determine his prison sentence.
Mango Park General Hospital Doctor Phillip Price is being sued by a former patient for amputating her foot. Nancy Fraser had a circulation issue in her leg which forced an amputation of one of her limbs. Unfortunately for Nancy, Dr. Price botched the surgery and amputated the wrong foot. Ms. Fraser already won a settlement from the hospital, but is now suing Dr. Price personally for pain and suffering. Judge James Porter presides over the case.
Ben Mitchell is being sued by one of his tenants for failure to fix a litany of problems with his rental unit. The shady landlord not only has issues with his tenant, but after insulting the court, now he must face the wrath of Judge Porter.
Self-described Fitness Guru Robert Medina is being sued by one of his clients for a lack of results. The plaintiff, Tony Nunzio, alleges that despite following Mr. Medina's fitness and meal plans he did not achieve the results as promised. However, Mr. Medina alleges that Mr. Nunzio constantly cheated on his diet and didn't train properly, and is counter suing him for negative comments made on social media. Judge Porter must decide who is to blame, while keeping his cool during Mr. Medina's clownish antics in the courtroom.
After a contentious breakup, Alyssa Rodriguez is suing her ex-boyfriend, John Evans. Alyssa claims John won't allow her back into the apartment to collect her personal belongings and is denying to share custody of their two pets. Meanwhile, Mr. Evans is seeking sole custody of their dog and will stop at nothing to ensure Alyssa doesn't win the case.
After being humiliated on the red carpet at a gala in Mango Park, billionaire Elizabeth Von Bonin is suing her fashion designer for one million dollars. Mrs. Von Bonin claims that not only was she humiliated at the star-studded event, but she was also defamed on social media. Conversely, the young fashion designer, Paula Rose is counter suing for $100,000, claiming Mrs. Von Bonin maliciously conspired to ruin her small business.
Once again, local entrepreneur Ben Mitchell finds himself in Mango Park District Court. This time he is being sued by a former customer of his exotic car rental business for providing sub-par service and in turn ruining his wedding day. Now, Judge Porter must decide who's to blame for this fiasco and hopefully contain any outbursts from Mr. Mitchell.