It's Columbus Day and for a History project, Charlotte and Brody decide to portray the ""true"" Christopher Columbus but it upsets their teacher who wanted all the students to enter the History contest and when Charlotte refuses to change it but Brody changes his, Brody's old friends tease him for being a ""goody good"" now and he ends up embarrassed and questioning Gaby why he has changed so much and if it's the better for him and in the end he vows to break his ""goody good"" mold. Korky urges Sean to take a road trip with him, while Colby continues to butt heads with Lucy and even toys around the idea of switching out of the class-just so she'll end up leaving him alone, but Lucy's friend Alexis convinces him otherwise. Beth joins the Youth Center and has to deal with Coulier, Jared and Teresa telling the young kids about Columbus after an angry Native-American child and parent spread about the ""truth"" but visiting Anna, Sarah, Gretchen and Kalyopie overhear and Kalyopie gets so angered s