Reverend James Chastain appears devastated when his wife, Theresa, tragically dies in a house fire. When detectives investigate a second fire a decade later, they begin to think the devout Reverend could be hiding a murderous secret.
The brutal murder of retired couple Leo and Hazel Gleese shocks the quiet town of Sebring, Florida. Their adopted son, the good Reverend John Canning, delivers a heartfelt eulogy. But detectives suspect his grief hides a shocking secret.