Did you know that co-creator/showrunner Damon Lindelof considers 'Homecoming' the worst episode they ever did of LOST? We are going to discuss why that is, and whether or not he's right. There are many problems with this Charlie-centric episode, including some underwhelming flashbacks and some anti-climatic on-island action, but are there any redeeming features? We will also answer several mysteries surrounding Ethan Rom, The Others, and untangling the series of events that happened to Claire during her time with them. But most importantly of all, we shall tackle the age old question: is it Scott or Steve?