After getting over the shock of Michael's ex-girlfriend Lauren joining them for dinner, Kate struggles to get her burgeoning relationship with Michael off on the right foot, only to be placed in an impossible situation when Lauren goes over her head to Jerry to force Kate to choose between Michael and handling Lauren's case. Meanwhile, Kate goes before Judge Blake, to try her case against reality TV producer Chuck Webb, whose completely manipulated show ""Honeymoon Hotel"" humiliated Kate's unwitting client Mia and led her to seek a divorce. The case becomes complicated by the fact that Judge Blake simultaneously hires Kate as her matchmaker and when the matches don't go so well, neither does Kate's case.