Rogers visits 15-year-old Chainey Umphrey III at the neighborhood gym. Also there is Chuck Aber, working with his H.J. Elephant III puppet. In a real rarity, Aber appears in the Neighborhood of Make-Believe working the H.J. Elephant III puppet. Together they visit Lady Elaine, who talks of a toy that no one has seen.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fred Rogers | Writer | ||
| Chainey Umphrey III | Guest Star | ||
| Paul Lally | Director |