Follow the exploits of four stay-at-home dads as they juggle the requirements and social expectations of being both a "modern man" and "Modern Dad." In this episode the guys help Rick plan the twins' first birthday party. Stone considers a vasectomy.
Nate over-commits to baby proofing the house. Rick steps in. Stone deals with a moral dilemma after being hit on by a married woman.
Rick goes on an all-juice diet with Stone as his mentor. Sean and Rachel find it difficult to have alone time and attempt to soundproof the bedroom.
The guys finally resume their weekly poker game. After the babysitter calls in sick, a surprise visitor crashes. Sean turns to Rachel to help his bluffing skills. Rachel challenges him to strip poker.
Rick attempts to make money by creating an online parenting video. Sean helps give it a little something extra. Stone takes Danica to Mommy and Me swim lessons and agrees to auction himself for charity after the Mommies insist.
Nate books a job; Rick is encouraged to get a minivan.
Stone builds a pergola in an attempt to impress a woman.
Rick loses his phone; a trip to the zoo with the girls leads to a moral dilemma for Stone and Sean.
Sean goes engagement-ring shopping with Rick.