Admittedly picky first-time homebuyers Josie and Steve are hunting for a three-bedroom house for under $350,000 in the suburbs of Milwaukee. Determined to get a deal on their purchase, they reject several houses that don't live up to their expectations. When they find one that they like enough to bid on, Josie's brash negotiations push them to the brink of losing the deal. Then, when they're finally under contract, they endure a bit of a scare at inspection.