The girls are enjoying their night at Sweetheart's house. When bedtime comes, Patch tells a scary bedtime tale about a medieval Paradise Lake warrior named Squire, who failed his quest to tame the dragon Basil. The girls investigate the attic. The attic is dark and spooky but all they find is Sweethearts' cat Springfield. Back in the bedroom, Patch drifts off to sleep and sees the ghost of Squire who asks her to take care of some unfinished business. Episode Song: "Things Are Not Always What They Seem", sung by Patch.