In the pilot, two buddies who were once in love with the same woman reunite at the reading of the woman's will, where they learn that one of them -- but not which one -- fathered her 12-year-old daughter and that both are to share custody of the girl.
Michael insists the family move to his uptown apartment, which has no playmates for Nicole and no life as Joey knows it.
Nicole goes to the movies with a friend---and ends up in New Jersey.
Joey's lecture before Nicole's first date fails to cover what to do when the suitor fails to show up.
Nicole fixes Michael up with a neighbor, which amuses him then confuses him as their pairing becomes more and more ""comfortable.""
The two dads have dates on the same night, so they decide to let Nicole and her friends baby-sit themselves.
Joey agrees to join his father's plumbing business if he fails to make a sale at his one-man art show.
After Joey strikes out with a woman, Michael is a hit, but the victory is short-lived when the woman turns out to be Judge Wilbur's niece -- who's engaged.
Joey's protest over Nicole's failing art grade turns into a date with the teacher, which doesn't earn Joey high marks.
Michael is racked with guilt when business continually forces him to break dates with Nicole.
Joey and Michael anticipate their first Christmas with Nicole, but she's ignoring the holidays, her first without her mother.
Nicole's longing for a brother turns into a longing for equal time after the dads fulfill her request.
Joey feels picked on and Nicole feels deprived of her time with Cory when Michael's mother comes to visit.
Nicole wants the loft's racquetball championship called off after Michael's training regimen sends him to the hospital.
Joey's rock-star friend thinks Joey is spending too much time under the influence---of Michael.
Cory receives advice on kissing from Nicole's dads and his older brother.
Michael pulls some strings to cheer up Nicole after her first modeling audition is unsuccessful.
When Michael's estranged sister visits, Michael learns that Joey influenced her decision to leave her medical career.
A group of friends helps the dads survive Nicole's week away at camp.
Joey enlists Michael to coach him on the finer points of etiquette when he meets a debutante dream girl.
When a newspaper reporter writes an article criticizing Judge Wilbur, most specially, her decision to put Nicole with Joey and Michael, a television reporter decides to do feature on them by interviewing everyone involve and record Nicole with her two fathers and see who is right.
Corey tries to set his mom up with Klawicki.
Zach, a boy whom Nicole knew moves to New York and comes to see her. And Cory is not comfortable with her being with him.
When Nicole asks her more experienced girlfriend for kissing tips, Michael and Joey prepare for a fathers daughter talk by enrolling in a sexuality awareness seminar attended by a group of angry women over 30.
With Nicole away for the weekend, Michael and Joey resume a 15 year old bet that one of them can get their high school "no" queen of all time to say "yes" to a date.
Lifestyles and temperaments change dramatically in the Taylor/Harris household when Michael loses his job and Joey goes to work.
A visit from her rock and roll idol Malcolm O'Dell leaves Nicole star-struck until the musician loses his music making ability.
When 14 year old Nicole comes home with liquor on her breath, the Dads employ their own brand of shock therapy: a vivid and frightening demonstration of the dangers of alcohol abuse.
When a man whom the judge sent to prison sends her death threats, she's assigned someone to protect her--Bull Shannon from Night Court.
Nicole rebels when Joey ignores her objections to his dating a hot but condescending woman. Her revenge? She goes out with every fathers nightmare someone named Chopper.
After Joey gets caught with a girl in the house, Nicole tells all of her friends, who now worships Joey like he is ""The God Of Love"" Is it more than Joey bargained for?
Through a series of dreams, Nicole has a chance to see what life would have been like if her mother had married either Michael or Joey.
Michael is excited and Joey apprehensive as they begin their jobs together at a new financial magazine, but emotions mix when they meet their boss, Karen, an attractive and assertive woman.
In order to distract her over protective dads, Nicole introduces them to a beautiful new neighbor.
Nicole's best friend Shelby falls in love with... her dad?
When Nicole fails to make the basketball team, Joey confronts her coach who turns out to be a very competitive woman both on and off the court.
Michael's uncle shows up and he's not exactly pleased to see him. It seems he has a habit of making promises that he doesn't keep. And he's making some to Nicole.
Nicole decides to drop out of an advanced English class - with best friend Shelby's encouragement, after overhearing Michael and Joey disdainfully discussing their "smart" boss, Karen.
Michael is out dating again; but this time, he finds himself dating Nicole's boyfriend's mother! Hilarity at it's best!
Joey decides to be considerate and watch his girlfriends baby Gracie. It decides to be more then the two men can handle, as the baby ends up staying all night; distrupting Michael's work, and waking up dear Judge Wilbur in the process.
Nicole is dating a slightly older guy. When the guys hear about this, they forbid her to see him. She sneaks out to see him. They follow her and discover her getting her heart broken.
Shelby is dating a guy whom Nicole says is a creep. But Shelby ignores her. So to prove it to her, Nicole goes on a double date with them and the guy's friend. And sure enough his true self comes out but Shelby finds it hard to accept.
Joey holds a bachelor party for a friend at his place. He ends up meeting a lady friend; a wrestler, and then ends up... marrying her? How will he get out of this one? You have to see it to believe it.
Nicole becomes depressed as she wants to wishes to an adult. Her dads try to cheer her up and make her see the advantages of being a teenager.
It's the homecoming dance at Nicole's school. And the teacher in charge goes to see Joey and Michael to see if they have any suggestions. They're both taken with her and they come up with a girls asking out the boys. And Nicole finds herself in a delicate position cause this where she decides if she wants to be with Cory or Zach. And when she makes her choice, someone else asks him out.
After being burgalarized Joey and Michael create their own watch program so Nicole will safe. But it's Michael who's feeling apprehensive and leads to being trapped on the roof.
Michael and Joey's parenting styles continue to clash so they decide submit to a DNA test. They agree that whoever is not the biological father will step aside. While waiting for the results they learn something more important.
Joey and Michael are trapped in an elevator leading them to recall interesting moments of the last several years. Nicole, Margaret, and Shelby have trouble holding off eating dinner until the guys are freed.
Joey learns about an opening for an art teacher but he lacks the college degree required. He returns to school but discovers his instructor is Mr. Kelcher who he clashed with in the past.
It's the holidays, and Joey is dreaming of what holidays and life would be like if they were older; a lot older.
Frustrated by how much time Nicole is spending with Zach -- and by the fact they seem to be invisible when the two are together -- Michael and Joey declare that she must date someone else for awhile.
Joey is stunned when he learns that his girlfriend Sarah, and her baby Gracie are both moving away to San Francisco.
Joey gets thrown in jail for environmental protests, when Michael, .. and Judge Wilbur have to bail him out.
Nicole's sweet sixteen party gets cancelled due to... appendicitis?
Joey finally gets himself in the paper.. in the obituary section? Joey Marris's obituary, printed as Joey Harris, finally appears in the paper as dead; leaving art galleries calling to Joey for loads of money for his artwork, and pretending that he is dead.
Joey's old high school flame comes back to New York, and gets attracted to Michael.
When Judge Wilbur's going to be honored, Joey, Michael, and Nicole think that it would nice for some her friends and family were there. Only problem is that they don't know any of her friends and family and if she has any. So they do a little snooping around and find some of her things that were hidden and in it is a picture of her and someone named Louis and they thought he was a friend so they invite him. Only thing he came under the assumption that they told her that he was and when they meet, Judge Wilbur's not happy to see him. They (Joey, Michael, and Nicole) learn that he's her ex-husband. It seems that years ago she thought her career was more important, so they went their separate ways. They arrange for her and Louis to be alone together, and they make peace.
Nicole learns she's not considered part of the in crowd and considers extreme measures to change her status. Joey's girlfriend won't accept their breakup so he makes up a new romance.
Nicole enters a Rock TV music channel contest in which Nicole wins and gets to go on a musical dream date of her choice... and her dads get to live out their own fantasies in the process. Michael playing the piano live in front of a national TV audience, and Joey playing basketball.. with Dr. J? Special Guest Stars ------------------- Dr. Julius Erving as himself Bobby Rydell as himself
In the series grand finale, Joey's girlfriend Sarah wants to get married.. with another guy. Joey stops the wedding and gets back together with Sarah, and is faced with a tough choice. Move to San Francisco, or stay with Nicole in New York.
Staci Keanan and Greg Evigan sit down and discuss their time on the show.
