Hitting a dead end, the group calls for reinforcements in the form of their podcast’s Superfans.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Matteo Borghese | Writer | ||
| Rob Turbovsky | Writer | ||
| Teddy Coluca | Guest Star | Lester | |
| Aaron Dominguez | Guest Star | Óscar Torres | |
| Da'Vine Joy Randolph | Guest Star | Detective Donna Williams | |
| Amy Ryan | Guest Star | Jan Bellows | |
| Jayne Houdyshell | Guest Star | Bunny Folger | |
| Julian Cihi | Guest Star | Tim Kono | |
| Jackie Hoffman | Guest Star | Uma Heller | |
| Martin Short | Executive Producer | ||
| Dan Fogelman | Executive Producer | ||
| Selena Gomez | Executive Producer | ||
| Jess Rosenthal | Executive Producer | ||
| John Hoffman | Executive Producer | ||
| Jamie Babbit | Executive Producer | ||
| Steve Martin | Executive Producer | ||
| Cherien Dabis | Director | ||
| Steve Martin | Creator | ||
| John Hoffman | Creator |