Paul Rader is forced into hiding with his family after he's falsely accused of murder and the real killer threatens his children. The Raders settle in a small Iowa town under assumed names as Paul searches for clues to clear his name.
Paul agrees to meet a mystery person at the train station. Hannah gets invited to a party and offers to bring the liquor so she can fit in. She asks Henry to use his fake ID to get it and he gets arrested. Then she gets drunk and almost tells everyone everything about her family's secret.
Paul chances a return to Washington, D.C., to follow up on a lead involving the key he found in his pocket after meeting with Tannen. Meanwhile, Hannah lies about having had sex before, Henry gets everyone fake IDs, Tommy loses a spelling bee, and Lily starts working at the hospital.
Hannah tries to help Brady pass his English class by switching his paper with one of her old ones, so he can play football in the homecoming game. Paul worries that someone might have followed him from Washington.
Gina confides in Paul and Lily about hiding out from her ex-husband Randy, who has surprisingly showed up in Bridgewater. Paul's father also has a heart attack and Paul is debating if he should go visit him.
Kylie and Henry agree to meet up in St. Louis, unaware that the FBI has followed Kylie. Meanwhile, Hannah and Brady share a kiss after he confesses his feelings for her.
As their world is turned upside down when the U.S. Marshals use Henry's girlfriend to contact them, Paul and Lily uncover evidence that suggests lawyer Lloyd Cunningham was involved with Erin's murder.
A tornado puts Tommy's life in danger and threatens to expose the Rader family's secret.
Paul's efforts to get Cunningham to reveal what he knows about Erin's murder spawns a surprising confession that leaves the Rader family facing the most difficult decision of their lives.
