Caitlin is still trying to tell Cole about her miscarriage, but she just can't do that, and Cole interrupts her, thinking of something totally else, their wedding. Tyus asks Caitlin about what happened to her friend who miscarried, and Caitlin tells him that her friend is infertile, so Tyus advises her to tell her friend to adopt a baby. Mark plays a little with the people on the boat -- he tells them a a story about a group of people who came to a party and were all murdered. He offers them a game to find a murder weapon, unaware of what is happening. Meg and Gabi go down to the basement together, where they find a doll hanging from a noose. Casey scares Michael and Vanessa on the boat, and Sean scares Meg, but it's all just a game.