Cole and Caitlin talk about what Cole discovered, and Caitlin tells Cole that A.J. Deschanel was Olivia's first love. Just when Bette and Annie made up, the tape that Annie made starts playing, and Bette realizes what Annie is up to. Hurt by her actions, Bette tells Annie that she's going to Hell just like her father and decides to cut all ties with her. Annie tries to explain why she did, but Bette won't listen and she leaves. A unknown man stops Olivia from jumping and they start talking. He takes her to his cabin where he presents himself as her friend. Gregory finds Annie crying.