Gregory asks Annie to sign an insurance claim form for the Faberge egg that she told him was broken the previous night, reminding her that falsifying an insurance claim form is a felony. She never gets around to signing it. Olivia tells Gregory and Annie that she's heard about a professional prank caller who makes vague threats, but never says exactly what he's calling about. Caitlin tells the blackmailer that she needs more time to get the money. They keep the caller on the line long enough to trace it, but the tracer says that they haven't gotten any phone calls.