Cole warns Olivia that he'll fight for Caitlin if he has to. Caitlin advises Gregory to tell Olivia that he loves her. Gregory and Caitlin catch Cole and Olivia in the room together, but they say they were only talking about Caitlin. Gregory later confronts Olivia about her pregnancy. Meg is surprised to see the effort that Ben went through to arrange a perfect time for them, but she keeps remembering the past and realizes that it will always be there. Ben tries to assure her that he wants to be with her. Annie, who has been eavesdropping the entire time, learns that Ben has no idea that he made love to Meg in the cave. She confronts Meg about it.