Timmy ist es leid, dass er nicht mal beim Eislaufen mit seiner angebeteten Trixie ein paar Pirouetten als Paar drehen kann. Also wünscht er sich von seinen helfenden Elfen Cosmo und Wanda, dass er und Trixie allein auf der Welt sind. Doch schon bald bemerkt Timmy, dass er allein Trixie nicht die Anerkennung und Aufmerksamkeit zuteil werden lassen kann, die sie fortwährend erwartet. Er versucht, seinen Wunsch rückgängig zu machen....
At the ice-skating rink, Timmy wants to be partners with Trixie. Other boys go to her first, so Timmy tries to guarantee that, by wishing that he would be the only boy at school. However, a boy from another school goes to her first. So he wishes that he and Trixie were the only two people on earth! Even that fails when Mark the alien goes to her first. Finally, he says a detailed wish and his dream comes true. The problem is: Trixie is needy and "goes nuts" when she is not adored by many boys.To make matters worse, Trixie is very messy with break-ups; like using an attack helicopter.
Timmy, non riuscendo a ballare con Trixie, è stufo di vederla da tutti desiderata. Quindi desidera che lui, Trixie e i suoi Fantagenitori siano gli unici abitanti dell'universo. Purtroppo Trixie si rivelerà molto ossessiva, perché vuole sempre ricevere complimenti da Timmy, e quest'ultimo, stancandosi, si nasconderà da lei. Così Trixie cercherà di ucciderlo in quanto non riceve più i complimenti da Timmy.
