While riding the subway on his way to a Halloween costume party, Jonathan meets the girl of his dreams dressed in a Cinderella costume. Jonathan places an ad in the newspaper and rides the subway to find her again. Russell studies for a law exam.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stephen Godchaux | Writer | ||
| Rachel Sweet | Writer | ||
| Silas Weir Mitchell | Guest Star | ||
| David Doty | Guest Star | ||
| Bari Willerford | Guest Star | ||
| Tatjana Patitz | Guest Star | Fairy on Train | |
| Julie Benz | Guest Star | ||
| Craig Zisk | Director |