The investigation into a possible serial killer in Chillicothe, Ohio, is chronicled in this series. In 2014, four women vanish; two more are later found dead; a fifth goes missing; and, before the last case can be investigated, another body is found.
Another body is found during the search for the fifth missing woman; and an anonymous tip points the police to a possible suspect within hours.
When two bodies are found in the same area one year apart, people wonder if it could be a serial killer’s dumping ground. Connections between two victims become clearer as one investigation is revisited.
The police discover that one of the missing women knew one of the women found dead; and news of another missing girl sends Chillicothe into a panic.
The search for a pregnant 20-year-old concludes; and the search for another missing woman kicks into high gear.
In the finale, the police pursue a new lead in a nearby town; and Jason McCrary, accused of murdering Timberly Claytor, goes to trial.