Dylan and Patrick struggle with the revelation that they need a little help in their relationship and Dylan isn't quite convinced that Patrick's suggestion of adding another person is the answer.
Dylan and Patrick scan the web for candidates for their first three-way but they have trouble deciding on the best person to choose.
Patrick is gung-ho about finding new partners to have sex with while Dylan wants to slow it down. But Patrick has already invited Jason, a new acquaintance he met at the gym, over for the evening and he convinces Dylan to just go along with it.
After a night together, Dylan and Jason get to know one another the next morning while Patrick sleeps.
Patrick's brother is in town and comes over for a visit. Things take a turn when the brother is introduced to Jason and old rivalries and jealousy rise to the surface.
Dylan tries to convince Jason to stop coming over and all hell breaks loose when Patrick finds out.