After being caught by her boyfriend with her girlfriend, Vanessa decides to hit the bar and drink her night away. There she meets Justin and the two immediately hit it off.
Justin and Vanessa's friends meet during a night of playing "never have I ever." Vanessa slips that she's been with women piquing the curiosity of Justin and disapproval of Erica.
After finally having sex with Justin, Vanessa meets with Dezi & Erica to explain the type of relationship she has always wanted.
Paying homage to the 80's classics Weird Science & Coming to America, Vanessa & Justin hit the club scene to find their perfect woman.
After a failed attempt at speed dating, Justin & Vanessa propose to a stripper only for it to blow up in their faces.
While at lunch with friends, Vanessa & Justin meet the enchanting Madison. While waiting on her to call, the couple decides to answer a craigslist post as a last-ditch effort.
Jealous of her budding relationship with another woman, Erica confronts Vanessa while she's out on a date demanding her to choose between friendship or love.
Still angry at Vanessa, Erica informs Vanessa's mother about her bisexual encounters. Madison finally calls, and Justin & Vanessa prepare for their first date.