Panelists feature a U.S. Quidditch team champion, a professional cheese sculptor, one of the original members of N*SYNC, the inventor of a glitter bomb, and someone who helped to catch a serial killer.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Joel McHale | Guest Star | ||
| Oliver Hudson | Guest Star | ||
| Nikki Glaser | Guest Star | ||
| Vivica A. Fox | Guest Star |