From "Macho Man" Randy Savage battling Ricky "The Dragon" Steamboat to WrestleMania 35's historic Women's Triple Threat Match, WWE Superstars celebrate more awesome WrestleMania moments.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gionna Daddio | Guest Star | Liv Morgan | |
| Michael Hickenbottom | Guest Star | Shawn Michaels | |
| Austin Watson | Guest Star | Xavier Woods | |
| Dave Bautista | Guest Star | Batista | |
| Bret Hart | Guest Star | Bret Hart | |
| Megan O'Brien | Guest Star | Megan Morant | |
| Walter Hahn | Guest Star | Gunther | |
| Scott Hall | Guest Star | Scott Hall (archive footage) | |
| Thomas Pestock | Guest Star | Baron Corbin | |
| Luis Martínez | Guest Star | Damian Priest | |
| Kofi Sarkodie-Mensah | Guest Star | Kofi Kingston | |
| Óscar Gutiérrez | Guest Star | Rey Mysterio | |
| Natalya | Guest Star | Natalya | |
| James Hellwig | Guest Star | Warrior (archive footage) | |
| Khleo Thomas | Guest Star | Khleo Thomas | |
| Kurt Angle | Guest Star | Kurt Angle | |
| Yuvraj Dhesi | Guest Star | Jinder Mahal | |
| Richard Blood Sr. | Guest Star | Ricky Steamboat | |
| John Gargano | Guest Star | Johnny Gargano | |
| Mark Calaway | Guest Star | Undertaker | |
| Colby Lopez | Guest Star | Seth "Freakin" Rollins | |
| Samantha Johnson | Guest Star | Samantha Irvin | |
| Kevin Kesar | Guest Star | Karrion Kross | |
| Paul Lévesque | Guest Star | Triple H | |
| Samuel Roberts | Guest Star | Sam Roberts | |
| Ettore Ewen | Guest Star | Big E | |
| Sean Coulthard | Guest Star | Michael Cole | |
| Steve Austin | Guest Star | Stone Cold Steve Austin | |
| Charles Betts | Guest Star | Chad Gable | |
| Tommaso Whitney | Guest Star | Tommaso Ciampa | |
| Shelton Benjamin | Guest Star | Shelton Benjamin | |
| John Layfield | Guest Star | JBL | |
| Terry Bollea | Guest Star | Hulk Hogan | |
| Stuart Bennett | Guest Star | Wade Barrett | |
| Rebecca Quin | Guest Star | Becky Lynch |